One investor flips. The other holds.
At purchase, both investors acquire the same type of property. The difference emerges in what happens next.
Investor A renovates the building and sells it shortly after completion. Investor B places tenants in the units and operates the property as a rental. From the IRS’s perspective, that difference drives the tax outcome.
The tax code distinguishes between property held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of a trade or business. That determination is based on the facts and circumstances surrounding how the property is used and sold, not on the type of property itself.
When a property is treated as held primarily for sale, the gain is generally treated as ordinary income. When it is treated as held for investment, the gain may be eligible for capital gain treatment. As a result, two investors can sell the same quadplex for the same profit and still report that income very differently, based solely on how the property was used.
This means two investors can sell the same quadplex for the same profit and still report that income in fundamentally different ways, based on how the property was used.
Both earn over $120,000. One operates through an LLC. The other is through an S corporation.
Investor A operates through an LLC using default tax treatment. Investor B operates through an S corporation and actively provides services related to real estate activities. That structural choice changes how income is reported.
When an S corporation shareholder performs services for the business, the IRS requires the corporation to pay reasonable compensation as wages before taking distributions. This is a reporting requirement tied to how income is earned, not to the type of property owned.
An LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship or partnership follows a different reporting path. Income flows through based on ownership and activity, without the same wage-versus-distribution framework.
The result is that two investors with the same property and similar income levels can face different tax mechanics and compliance obligations, driven by structure rather than performance.
How depreciation and holding period change the result
Even when both investors choose to hold the quadplex as a rental, timing can meaningfully change the outcome.
Investor A has held the property for several years and claims depreciation annually. Investor B holds the property for a shorter period and claims less depreciation before selling. Over time, depreciation reduces the property’s adjusted basis.
When the property is sold, that adjusted basis affects how much of the sale proceeds are treated as taxable gain. The holding period also affects how the gain is categorized and reported.
As a result, two investors can sell the same quadplex for the same price and still report different taxable gains, based on depreciation taken and the timing of the sale.
In each case, the difference in tax outcome does not come from the quadplex itself. It comes from the choices surrounding it:
These are classification and reporting issues grounded in IRS rules, not shortcuts or aggressive tactics. Understanding how those decisions interact is often what separates a clean filing from unexpected surprises.
If you are making a pivotal decision about your real estate business and are unsure how it may be treated for tax purposes, it’s worth getting clarity before moving forward. A real estate tax advisor can help you understand how classification, structure, and timing may affect reporting and outcomes.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is based on IRS guidance available for the 2025 tax year. Tax treatment depends on individual facts and circumstances. This content is not tax advice and should not be relied on as a substitute for working with a qualified tax professional.
When it comes to reliable accounting services in Atlanta, GA, look no further than Accolade Accounting. With a highly experienced accountant team, we have assisted numerous businesses in developing and implementing effective accounting systems. If you need expert guidance, don’t hesitate to contact our certified public accountants, call 470-646-2663
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended as tax advice. Tax situations vary, and IRS rules can change. Always consult with a qualified tax professional regarding your specific circumstances.
